Many people will soon be picking their health insurance plans for 2024: November is a common month for workplace open enrollment, and the public marketplace opens Nov. 1.
But choosing a health plan can be tricky.
In fact, a 2017 study found many people lose money due to suboptimal choices: Sixty-one percent chose the wrong plan, costing them an average $372 a year. The paper, authored by economists at Carnegie Mellon University and the Wisconsin School of Business, examined choices made by almost 24,000 workers at a U.S. firm.
More from Personal Finance:
‘Cash stuffing’ may forgo ‘easiest money’ you can make
These credit cards have had ‘increasingly notable’ high rates
Home ‘affordability is incredibly difficult,’ economist says
Health plans have many moving parts, like premiums and deductibles. Each has financial implications for buyers.
“It is confusing, and people have no idea how much they could potentially have to pay,” Carolyn McClanahan, a certified financial planner and founder of Life Planning Partners, based in Jacksonville, Florida, previously told CNBC. McClanahan is also a medical doctor and a member of CNBC’s FA Council.
Making a mistake can be costly; consumers are generally locked into their health insurance for a year, with limited exception.
Here’s a guide to the major cost components of health insurance and how they may impact your bill.
The premium is the sum you pay an insurer each month to participate in a health plan.
It’s perhaps the most transparent and easy-to-understand cost component of a health plan — the equivalent of a sticker price.
The average premium paid by an individual worker was $1,401 a year — or about $117 a month — in 2023, according to a survey on employer-sponsored health coverage from the Kaiser Family Foundation, a nonprofit. Families paid $6,575 a year, or $548 a month, on average.
Your monthly payment may be higher or lower depending on the type of plan you choose, the size of your employer, your geography and other factors.
Low premiums don’t necessarily translate to good value. You may be on the hook for a big bill later if you see a doctor or pay for a procedure, depending on the plan.
“When you’re shopping for health insurance, people naturally shop like they do for most products — by the price,” Karen Pollitz, co-director of KFF’s program on patient and consumer protection, previously told CNBC.
“If you’re shopping for tennis shoes or rice, you know what you’re getting” for the price, she said. “But people really should not just price shop, because health insurance is not a commodity.
“The plans can be quite different” from each other, she added.
Many workers also owe a copayment — a flat-dollar fee — when they visit a doctor. A “co-pay” is a form of cost-sharing with health insurers.
The average patient pays $26 for each visit to a primary-care doctor and $44 to visit a specialty care physician, according to KFF.
Patients may owe additional cost-sharing like co-insurance, a percentage of health costs that the consumer shares with the insurer. This cost-sharing generally kicks in after you’ve paid your annual deductible (a concept explained more fully below).
The average co-insurance rate for consumers is 19% for primary care and 20% for specialty care, according to KFF data. (The insurer would pay the other 81% and 80% of the bill, respectively.)
As an example: If a specialty service costs $1,000, the average patient would pay 20% — or $200 — and the insurer would pay the remainder.
Co-pays and co-insurance may vary by service, with separate classifications for office visits, hospitalizations or prescription drugs, according to KFF. Rates and coverage may also differ for in-network and out-of-network providers.
Deductibles are another common form of cost-sharing.
This is the annual sum a consumer must pay out of pocket before the health insurer starts to pay for services.
Ninety percent of workers with single coverage have a deductible in 2023, according to KFF. Their average general annual deductible is $1,735.
The deductible meshes with other forms of cost-sharing.
Here’s an example based on a $1,000 hospital charge. A patient with a $500 deductible pays the first $500 out of pocket. This patient also has 20% co-insurance, and therefore pays another $100 (or, 20% of the remaining $500 tab). This person would pay a total $600 out of pocket for this hospital visit.
Health plans may have more than one deductible — perhaps one for general medical care and another for pharmacy benefits, for example, Pollitz said.
Family plans may also assess deductibles in two ways: by combining the aggregate annual out-of-pocket costs of all family members, and/or by subjecting each family member to a separate annual deductible before the plan covers costs for that member.
The average deductible can vary widely by plan type: $1,281 in a preferred provider organization (PPO) plan; $1,200 in a health maintenance organization (HMO) plan; $1,783 in a point of service (POS) plan; and $2,611 in a high-deductible health plan, according to KFF data on single coverage. (Details of plan types are in more detail below.)
5. Out-of-pocket maximum
Most people also have an “out-of-pocket maximum.”
This is a limit on the total cost sharing consumers pay during the year — including co-pays, co-insurance and deductibles.
“The insurer can’t ask you for a co-pay at the doctor or pharmacy, or hit you for more deductibles,” Pollitz said. “That’s it; you’ve given your pound of flesh.”
About 99% of workers with single coverage are in a plan with an out-of-pocket maximum in 2023, according to KFF.
The range can be large. For example, 13% of workers with single coverage have an out-of-pocket maximum of less than $2,000, but 21% have one of $6,000 or more, according to KFF data.
Out-of-pocket maximums for health plans purchased through an Affordable Care Act marketplace can’t exceed $9,100 for individuals or $18,200 for a family in 2023.
Health insurers treat services and costs differently based on their “network.”
“In-network” refers to doctors and other health providers that are part of an insurer’s preferred network. Insurers sign contracts and negotiate prices with these in-network providers. This isn’t the case for “out-of-network” providers.
Here’s why that matters: Deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums are much higher when consumers seek care outside their insurer’s network — generally about double the in-network amount, McClanahan said.
Further, there’s sometimes no cap at all on annual costs for out-of-network care.
“Health insurance really is all about the network,” Pollitz said.
“Your financial liability for going out of network can be really quite dramatic,” she added. “It can expose you to some serious medical bills.”
Some categories of plans disallow coverage for out-of-network services, with limited exception.
For example, HMO plans are among the cheapest types of insurance, according to Aetna. Among the tradeoffs: The plans require consumers to pick in-network doctors and require referrals from a primary care physician before seeing a specialist.
Similarly, EPO plans also require in-network services for insurance coverage, but generally come with more choice than HMOs.
POS plans require referrals for a specialist visit but allow for some out-of-network coverage. PPO plans generally carry higher premiums but have more flexibility, allowing for out-of-network and specialist visits without a referral.
“Cheaper plans have skinnier networks,” McClanahan said. “If you don’t like the doctors, you may not get a good choice and have to go out of network.”
How to bundle it all together
Budget is among the most important considerations, Winnie Sun, co-founder and managing director of Sun Group Wealth Partners in Irvine, California, previously told CNBC. She’s also a member of CNBC’s FA Council.
For example, would you struggle to pay a $1,000 medical bill if you require health care? If so, a health plan with a larger monthly premium and a smaller deductible may be your best bet, Sun said.
Similarly, older Americans or those who require a lot of health care each year — or who expect to have a costly procedure in the coming year — may do well to pick a plan with a bigger monthly premium but better cost-sharing.
Healthy people who generally don’t max out their health spending every year may find it cheaper overall to have a high-deductible plan, McClanahan said.
Consumers who enroll in a high-deductible plan should use their monthly savings on premiums to fund a health savings account, advisors said. HSAs are available to consumers who enroll in a high-deductible plan.
“Understand the first dollars and the potential last dollars when picking your insurance,” McClanahan said, referring to upfront premiums and back-end cost-sharing.
Every health plan has a “summary of benefits and coverage,” which presents key cost-sharing information and plan details uniformly across all health insurance, Pollitz said.
“I’d urge people to spend a little time with the SBC,” she said. “Don’t wait until an hour before the deadline to take a look. The stakes are high.”
Further, if you’re currently using a doctor or network of providers you like, ensure those providers are covered under your new insurance plan if you intend to switch, McClanahan said. You can consult an insurer’s in-network online directory or call your doctor or provider to ask if they accept your new insurance.
The same rationale goes for prescription drugs, Sun said: Would the cost of your current prescriptions change under a new health plan?